Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Reviews For Sensitive Eyes
Whether you experienced allergic reactions before or would like to try out new, natural and gentle products, switching to hypoallergenic eyeliner is a great way to keep your eye area safe without any irritation. From the best hypoallergenic eyeliners to application tips and ingredient lists, our Hypoallergenic Eyeliner reviews contain all the information you need to know before making a purchase.
8 Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliners
1Almay Liquid Eyeliner Pen
If you are just starting to experiment with makeup, this is a great go-to hypoallergenic eyeliner for you! Instead of a thin brush, the Almay Liquid Eyeliner Pen features a felt tip pen that will guide your moves, making you create your eye look easily. Almay also has a wide range of different hypoallergenic products, such as concealers, mascaras and brow gels. You can purchase this liner in black for a traditional makeup look, or black-brown, for a more natural finish.
- precise, felt tip applicator for smooth line
- rich color payoff
- gentle application
- available in different shades
- affordable, high street price
Our Advice: Use the Black Brown and gently smudge out the edges with a brush to create a natural, no-makeup makeup look.
2Clinique Brush-On Cream Liner
Another Clinique liner that you will love if you are going for a more natural look is our brush-on cream liner, which comes with a tiny brush and a creamy, waterproof liner with a longwearing formula. With this liner, you can easily achieve a smudgy, smokey eye look as well, just use the brush to blend after the application. The product comes in a little jar, but because of its unique formula, you won’t have to worry about the product drying out too quickly.
- a long lasting, easy to apply formula
- brush included
- allergy and ophthalmologist tested
- creamy texture
Our Advice: Create a smudgy cut crease look with the help of the included brush. After applying the product, smudge it out with the brush and add a matte black or dark grey shadow on top to keep everything in place.
3Inglot Gel Eyeliner
Inglot is a smaller, independent makeup brand, creating hypoallergenic and paraben-free makeup in exciting shades and formulas. The brand is known for making one of the most popular eyeliners on the market, which is the favorite of beauty bloggers as well. Their gel eyeliners not only come in a large variety of colors (from lighter shades such as beige to deep purple, green and black) and two finishes (glossy and matte), but they are also waterproof and smudge proof, ensuring your liner stays in place all day.
- easy to apply gel texture
- intense color payoff
- long-stay, waterproof formula
- rich pigmentation
- large variety of shades
Our Advice: Try a unique shade, such as their matte plum to create a bold, yet eye-safe makeup look.
4Physician’s Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum
Physician’s Formula creates cruelty and fragrance-free products at a very affordable price point. All of their products, including their liners are hypoallergenic, but If a beautiful feline flick or cat eye wasn’t enough, this eyeliner also offer a lash boosting solution as well. Instead of worrying about your eye safety or damaging your lashes, you can actually nourish them. We know, it sounds like magic, but because the serum is applied to the base of the lashes, it can reach and promote growth easily.
- paraben and fragrance-free formula
- suitable for contact lens wearers
- cruelty free
- lash nourishing formula
- easy to use pen applicator
Our Advice: Rock the Ultra Black shade and create a dramatic, geometric liner!
5Bourjois Khol & Contour
Instead of a gel or a liquid formula, this Bourjois liner features a classic, pencil khol texture. The French brand created this eyeliner with a soft, blendable formula and with vitamin E and natural wax to make the liner more pigmented and long lasting. This Bourjois khol pencil is available in seven different shades, ranging from purple and blue to black and ultra black, and is perfect for a softer, smudged eye look instead of the classic, thin lines.
- large color range
- a soft khol texture
- available in seven different shades
- contains natural ingredients
Our Advice: Use two different shades and blend them together effortlessly with the help of a fluffy blending brush.
6Neutrogena Nourishing Eye Liner
If you are looking for a very creamy eyeliner pencil that glides on and can be touched up easily while being safe to your eyes, this hypoallergenic Neutrogena eyeliner is for you. These pencils come in 4 different shades (black, grey, brown and twilight blue), and has a glossy finish to it, which will help you define your eyes even more.
- easy to touch up
- compliments eyeshadow beautifully with the glossy finish
- wide color range at an affordable price
- gentle texture that won’t irritate your eyes
Our Advice: Because it has a very soft formula, make sure to use an eye-primer before starting your look!
7Jane Iredale Eyeliner Pencil
If you would like to try out something new, you will love Jane Iredale cosmetics and their eyeliner pencils! The brand is vegan, hypoallergenic and cruelty-free, while offering a range of makeup products from brushes to eyeliners and lipsticks. Soft and pigmented, the Jane Iredale pencils will give you a long-lasting eye makeup look without causing any irritation.
- sold by independent, high-end brand
- available in 6 different shades (white, beige, brown/black, traditional brown, grey and black)
- a soft and gentle texture
- long lasting finish
Our Advice: To make your eyes appear larger, use the white liner in the inner corners and waterline of your eyes, and make them pop with the midnight blue shade.
8Clinique Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen
This Clinique Eyeliner is a true classic: a precise pen with super pigmented, waterproof formula, available in black and brown. Depending on what you’d like to achieve, you can easily create a super thin line or a bolder look with the help of a smudging brush. Because its liquid formula, we recommend keeping it away from the waterline.
- high pigmentation with dark shades such as black and brown
- a precise pen applicator, perfect for cat eyes
- allergy and ophthalmologist tested
- versatile product
- quick-dry, liquid texture
Our Advice: Use this liner in black to create traditional, timeless looks such as cat eyes with red lipstick
9The Body Shop Eyeliner Liquid
If you haven’t heard about The Body Shop’s makeup products yet, you are guaranteed to fall in love. Similarly to their amazing smelling, cruelty free shower gels, famous body butters and fair trade balms, their makeup products are skin and eye friendly as well, made from natural and fair trade ingredients. Their Eyeliner liquid is a classic formula that comes in an easy-to-control tip tube. Available in black and brown – go with black for an intense color payoff and with brown if would like to draw a subtle, natural line.
- suitable for contact lens wearers
- very precise application with the brush tip
- dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested
- cruelty free
Our Advice: Complement your light eyes with a stunning black eyeliner, or if you have green or brown eyes, choose the brown shade to emphasize their warm, rich color!
10What is Hypoallergenic Eyeliner?
Hypoallergenic makeup generally contains less ingredients that can cause an irritating or allergic reaction. If a product is dermatologist or ophthalmologist tested or contains only natural and organic ingredients, It will probably be more gentle to your skin and eyes. While it’s easier for skincare brands and products to be hypoallergenic, creating hypoallergenic eye makeup can be tricky because of the strong pigmentation, but there are quite a few on the market that are high quality without any irritable ingredients.
11How to Check if You Are Allergic to Eyeliner?
There can be various signs of allergic reactions – if you experience any of the symptoms below, make sure to check the ingredients and consider switching to more skin and eye-friendly products.
One of the most common symptoms affecting directly the eyes are red, sensitive and bloodshot eyes or tearing up, which will likely happen if you are using an irritable product in your waterline or inner corners of your eyes. But the allergic reaction doesn’t necessarily mean bloodshot eyes: it can also come in the form of rashes around your eyes, swollen eyelids, itching, smaller blisters or dry patches. In worse case scenarios, you can also experience multiple red bumps around your eyes.
Allergic reactions don’t always show up immediately – they can slowly become more and more noticeable if you’ve been constantly using a product. In case of noticing an allergic reaction, cut out the recent products one by one to see which one caused the irritation (eyeliner, mascara or maybe a new eye shadow palette.)
12Ingredients to Avoid When Choosing Hypoallergenic Makeup
If you have super sensitive eyes (or sensitive skin around your eyes), we recommend switching to hypoallergenic or more eye-friendly products, and in order to make sure you choose the right products, these are the ingredients on the red list:
- alpha-hydroxy acids
- dyes (for blue or other colored eyeliners and mascaras)
13What to Look For in Hypoallergenic Makeup
On the other hand, there are the ingredients and labels to look for. A product that is organic, perfume and generally fragrance free will probably cause less irritation. We know, it’s not easy to switch to 100% natural products, but your eye safety is the most important aspect in this case – and with the recommendations, you can still create beautiful eyeliner flicks.
If your find that your eyes or skin is hypersensitive, we recommend switching your entire makeup kit to natural and hypoallergenic products. We know, it can be a long process to find replacements for all the products you swear by, but besides your eyeliner, your mascara, eyeshadow palettes, primers and face products can also cause irritation.
14In Case of An Allergic Reaction
First and foremost, if you sense an allergic reaction, wash off the product with a gentle cleanser and wash your eyes properly with cold water. For accidents like that, keep eye drops in the fridge for sensitive eyes, which will help clean your eyes and calm them. For the skin around your eyes, apply a fragrance free lotion or serum to your under eye area, which will soothe and cool the area.
For the long term, try to cut out the irritable products from your makeup bag and switch to one of our recommendations in the list. Keep in mind that every product works differently on different people, so you might have to experiment around a bit until you find the perfect match for your eyes.
Also try to avoid putting on too much makeup if your eyes are generally tired: after an all-nighter or Friday night out with your friends, you might want to be super gentle with your eyes.
15Tips on Applying and Taking Off Eyeliner
Even if you apply hypoallergenic makeup, it’s important to apply and take it off in a gentle way to ensure that you don’t cause irritation.
- clean and moisturize your eye area and always use a gentle primer
- if your eyes are tired, use a few eye drops to brighten them
- during the day, keep makeup wipes and your drops in your bag tin case your eyes get dry
- if you use a gel liner or a different brush, make sure it’s always clean
Taking Off Tips:
- instead of rubbing, be gentle with your eyes
- if you chose a waterproof mascara or liner, use a remover oil or balm to dissolve the product
- pat your eyes and eye area dry with a dry, clean towel
16Brands to Check Out
Brands such as Almay, Clinique, Neutrogena, Inglot and Bare Minerals are also known to carry various other hypoallergenic products as well, such as single eyeshadows, foundations, mascaras, concealers and brow products. If you’d like to support smaller, independent brands that promote cruelty free products, check out Inglot, Youngblood or Bite Beauty, or look for brands on indie beauty marketplaces.